Introduction
Imagine biting into a towering open-faced sandwich, smothered in creamy cheese sauce, with crispy fries cascading down its sides. This is no ordinary sandwich; it’s the Horseshoe, Springfield, Illinois’ culinary claim to fame. But to think of Springfield solely in terms of this singular dish would be a disservice to a vibrant food scene that’s been quietly simmering beneath the surface. While Springfield is rightly celebrated for its profound historical significance, particularly its deep connection to Abraham Lincoln, this Midwestern capital city offers so much more than just historical landmarks. It’s a place where the echoes of the past meet a modern, evolving culinary landscape.
From comforting, time-honored recipes passed down through generations to exciting new eateries embracing global flavors, Springfield’s food scene is ready to surprise and delight. This guide isn’t just about finding a meal; it’s about embarking on a delicious journey through the heart of Illinois. Prepare to discover the must-try foods and the best restaurants in Springfield, revealing a culinary tapestry that’s richer and more diverse than you ever imagined. Whether you’re a history buff looking for a satisfying post-museum bite or a dedicated foodie seeking your next great culinary adventure, Springfield’s got a seat at the table for you.
Springfield’s Signature Dish: The Horseshoe Sandwich
Let’s begin with the legend: the Horseshoe sandwich. Its origin story is as intriguing as the dish itself. The Horseshoe was born in Springfield during the earlier part of the previous century. The Leland Hotel’s chef, Steven Tomko, is credited with its creation. The name “Horseshoe” comes from the shape of the ham that traditionally tops the sandwich. It’s been a local favorite ever since. The beauty of the Horseshoe is in its simplicity.
Typically, a classic Horseshoe consists of thick slices of toasted bread – usually Texas toast – acting as a foundation for a generous portion of meat. The original was with ham, however you can also find it with hamburger, turkey, chicken, or other delicious meats. Piles of crispy French fries are layered over the meat, all drenched in a rich, creamy cheese sauce. The sauce is crucial, and it’s often what distinguishes a truly great Horseshoe from a mediocre one. A good cheese sauce is smooth, flavorful, and coats everything perfectly.
To truly experience the Horseshoe, you need to know where to go. Fortunately, Springfield offers several excellent options:
D’Arcy’s Pint
This popular Irish pub is famous for its award-winning Horseshoe sandwiches. D’Arcy’s is known for its hearty portions and perfectly executed cheese sauce. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal with friends. Beyond the classic, D’Arcy’s also offers variations like the “Pony Shoe,” a smaller version, and specialty Horseshoes with different meats and toppings.
Obed & Isaac’s Microbrewery
This brewery not only serves up delicious craft beers, but also fantastic food, including a standout Horseshoe. The setting is unique, with a charming outdoor patio. Their horseshoe features high-quality ingredients and a flavorful cheese sauce that complements their beers perfectly. They often have creative takes on the Horseshoe as well, using beer cheeses or adding locally sourced ingredients.
Trying a Horseshoe in Springfield is a must; it’s a true taste of local culinary history. It’s more than just a sandwich; it’s a symbol of the city’s food culture.
Beyond the Horseshoe: Exploring Springfield’s Culinary Diversity
Springfield is more than just its iconic sandwich. A world of culinary delights awaits. Let’s explore some of the other tastes Springfield has to offer.
Italian Cuisine
Springfield has a strong Italian heritage, and this influence is reflected in its thriving Italian restaurant scene. For authentic Italian flavors, look no further than:
Saputo’s
A Springfield institution, Saputo’s has been serving up classic Italian dishes for decades. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the menu is packed with favorites like homemade pasta, lasagna, and hearty meat sauces. This is where you go for a taste of old-world Italian comfort. Their family recipes have been passed down for generations. Be sure to try their famous spaghetti!
American Comfort Food
Sometimes, you just crave classic American comfort food, and Springfield has you covered.
Dublin Pub
This popular spot offers all the comforting classics you would expect. From juicy burgers to crispy fries to delicious sandwiches, you’re sure to find what you’re looking for here.
Clover’s Corner Pub
Another popular spot known for its classic burgers and delicious comfort food.
International Flavors
The culinary scene in Springfield is growing and becoming more diverse. This is expressed through many different international influences.
Casa Real
Craving authentic Mexican cuisine? Casa Real offers a vibrant menu of traditional Mexican dishes. From flavorful tacos to enchiladas and fajitas. The atmosphere is festive and welcoming, perfect for a fun night out.
Thai Basil
For a taste of the East, Thai Basil offers a delicious menu of classic Thai dishes. From Pad Thai to spicy curries. It’s a local favorite for fresh, flavorful Thai food.
Gyro Stop
If you’re looking for quick bite with big flavor, Gyro Stop is the place to be. Serving up authentic gyros, souvlaki, and other Mediterranean specialties, this casual spot is perfect for a satisfying lunch or dinner.
Sweet Treats & Bakeries
No culinary exploration is complete without indulging in some sweet treats.
Three Twigs Bakery
This charming bakery offers a delectable selection of cakes, pastries, and other baked goods. Everything is made from scratch. Three Twigs is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Krekel’s Custard
This local favorite offers delicious custard desserts that are sure to please anyone. From sundaes to simple custard cones, you’re sure to enjoy the tasty treats here.
Unique Dining Experiences
Springfield offers some unique dining experiences that you won’t find anywhere else.
Farm-to-Table & Local Focus
Increasingly, Springfield restaurants are embracing the farm-to-table movement, emphasizing local ingredients and seasonal menus. Keep an eye out for restaurants that highlight local farms and producers. Several restaurants across the area are now working with local farms to get the freshest ingredients. This helps support local business as well as giving the patrons an enjoyable experience. Check with farmers’ markets to get the freshest produce.
Breweries & Pubs with Food
Springfield’s craft beer scene is booming, and many local breweries offer excellent food menus to complement their brews.
Anvil & Forge Brewing and Distilling
Enjoy quality food pairings with craft beers and spirits.
Engrained Brewing Company
Another local brewery that offers food alongside its craft beer selection.
Historical Dining
Mange on Main
This historic building offers a step back in time while enjoying delicious food.
Tips for Exploring Springfield’s Food Scene
To make the most of your culinary adventure in Springfield, keep these tips in mind:
Consider location: Springfield is broken down into different sections. Check restaurants near where you are staying or where you are visiting.
Hours of operation: Some places have differing hours so make sure to check.
Reservations: For a more fine dining experience, make sure to book a reservation.
Parking: Downtown parking can be difficult at times so be prepared.
Budget: Price points vary across the city. Check menus online before you commit to a dinner out.
Check reviews: Always read reviews before going out. Reviews are updated frequently, and this is a good way to find the hottest spots around town.
Conclusion
Springfield, Illinois, is a city where history and delicious food intertwine. From the legendary Horseshoe sandwich to a diverse array of international flavors, this capital city offers a culinary experience that’s sure to surprise and delight. It’s a place where you can savor a taste of local tradition, explore global flavors, and discover unique dining experiences that will leave you wanting more.
So, whether you’re a Springfield native or a first-time visitor, I encourage you to explore the city’s vibrant food scene. Venture beyond the well-trodden tourist paths, try something new, and discover the hidden culinary gems that await. Springfield isn’t just about history; it’s about creating delicious memories, one bite at a time. Come, experience the true taste of Springfield. It’s an adventure for your taste buds, and it’s waiting to be explored.
